help pick front cover

[dave]

as many of you knoe im doing a project for college, iv done the research etc now im onto the final thing, iv made to front covers, i wanna know what u think of them and what ones best, more feedback the better, the style im going for is a dark, grimey drum and bass music

attempt1
http://img408.imageshack.us/img408/9307/dsc00295copydq3.png

attempt2
http://img72.imageshack.us/img72/6079/difrontcoverfv9.png

[s4l]

2nd one :)

[the squid of despair]

1st one :)

[Santo]

1st looks better

[Q80Thug]

1st(Y)

[swiss miss]

1st one

[Buckledmac]

1st one Dave (y)

[tca]

can i phone a friend?

[Cheese on Toast]

#1 ;)

[curlybogtrotter]

The first one.

[Todd]

Both shite..

J/k lol, nice work Dave, i prefer the first one (Y)

[YetAnotherKitten]

I'm with the masses. DAMN YOU FOR MAKING ME A SHEEP!!! :(

first one kickas AASSSS!

[dave]

what wrong with the second lol

[Taste of Britain]

first 1

2nd one has to much flames n shit (y)

[dave]

i send u the original pic of the 2nd one then u can see why there is a flame in it

[Todd]

what wrong with the second lol

Nothing lol, just the first is better in my opinion :)

Although mabe bring the size of the stroke on the text down a tiny bit?

Just a thought (Y)

[dave]

but the styl im going for is dark and grimey, i personaly think the 2nd one is that and the 1st one isent

[the squid of despair]

but the styl im going for is dark and grimey, i personaly think the 2nd one is that and the 1st one isent


Then why ask our opinions?

[Todd]

but the styl im going for is dark and grimey, i personaly think the 2nd one is that and the 1st one isent

There both good Dave, and if i knew exactly what the cover was for i might think the same :)

[dave]

Then why ask our opinions?

because i cant just do something and hand it in because i like it, i have to get feedback and other peopls opinions, i got there opinions yes, but now im asking why they dident like the 2nd one, is that ok with you sir

[the squid of despair]

Is that ok with you sir

No :|

[Todd]

because i cant just do something and hand it in because i like it, i have to get feedback and other peopls opinions, i got there opinions yes, but now im asking why they dident like the 2nd one, is that ok with you sir

The reason i prefer the first one:

From what i thought, and as you said your going for the kinda London underground, grimey look, Bass / house music etc.

When i look at the second one with the flames it makes me think of rock / mosher music. Plus i don't think the white bit across the bottom looks right, stands out abit too much for me..

So that's why i prefer the first :)

P.S. The font on the first one works like a charm (Y)

[Santo]

i agree with Kons, the fonts is what made me choose the first one

[Buzzin]

Its blatantly the picture of James from thomas the tank engine in the first picture that makes everyone like it better :D

[JONNY.P]

1one(Y)

[dave]

Its blatantly the picture of James from thomas the tank engine in the first picture that makes everyone like it better :D

its actually thomas lol, my nephew loves him, all he says that u can understand is "chu chu"

[tca]

i personally liked the second one better, cos i suspected that was the look you were going for, but s4l picked it and i don't agree with that twat, so im asking for a 3rd option :D

[YetAnotherKitten]

Its blatantly the picture of James from thomas the tank engine in the first picture that makes everyone like it better :D

DUH!!

(so glad you know that hahahaha)